Skip to content

3. Kārakakappa (Kāraka chapter)

· 107 min read

The kāraka chapter defines the relations a noun bears to the action of its sentence — agent, object, instrument, recipient, source, owner and location — and assigns the seven inflection forms to them.

§271 (88, 308): Yasmā dapeti bhayamādatte vā tadapādānaṃ (that from which one departs, fears or takes: apādāna) anvattha

Section titled “§271 (88, 308): Yasmā dapeti bhayamādatte vā tadapādānaṃ (that from which one departs, fears or takes: apādāna) anvattha ”

Yasmā vā apeti, yasmā vā bhayaṃ jāyate, yasmā vā ādatte, taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Gāmā apenti munayo, nagarā niggato rājā, corā bhayaṃ jāyate, ācariyupajjhāyehi sikkhaṃ gaṇhāti sisso.

Apādānamiccanena kvattho? Apādāne pañcamī.

The kāraka from which one departs, from which fear arises, or from which one takes is termed apādāna (the point of departure).


§272 (309): Dhātunāmānamupasaggayogādīsvapi ca (and [the term] with certain roots, nouns, prefixes and the like) anvattha

Section titled “§272 (309): Dhātunāmānamupasaggayogādīsvapi ca (and [the term] with certain roots, nouns, prefixes and the like) anvattha ”

Dhātunāmānaṃ payoge ca upasaggayogādīsvapi ca taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

That kāraka is termed apādāna also in construction with roots and nouns, and in construction with prefixes and the like as well.

Dhātūnaṃ payoge tāva ji iccetassa dhātussa parāpubbassa payoge yo asaho, so apādānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Buddhasmā parājenti aññatitthiyā.

Bhū iccetassa dhātussa papubbassa payoge yato acchinnappabhavo, so apādānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Himavatā pabhavanti pañca mahānadiyo, anavatattamhā pabhavanti mahāsarā, aciravatiyā pabhavanti kunnadiyo.

To begin with, in construction with roots: in construction with the root ji preceded by parā, the one who cannot be withstood (asaha) is termed apādāna; and in construction with the root bhū preceded by pa, that from which [something] has its unbroken source (acchinnappabhava) is termed apādāna.

Nāmappayogepi taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Urasmā jāto putto, bhūmito niggato raso, ubhato sujāto putto mātito ca pitito ca.

In construction with a noun too, that kāraka is termed apādāna.

Upasaggayoge taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Apasālāya āyanti vāṇijā, ābrahmalokā saddo abbhuggacchati pari2 pabbatā devo vassati, buddhasmā pati sāriputto dhammadesanāya bhikkhū ālapati temāsaṃ, ghatamassa telasmā pati dadāti, uppalamassa padumasmā pati dadāti, kanakamassa hiraññasmā pati dadāti.

In construction with a prefix (upasagga), that kāraka is termed apādāna.3

Ādiggahaṇena kārakamajjhepi pañcamīvibhatti hoti. Ito pakkhasmā vijjhati migaṃ luddako, kosā vijjhati kuñjaraṃ, māsasmā bhuñjati bhojanaṃ.

By the mention of ādi (“and the like”), the fifth inflection ⑤ is used also in the middle of a kāraka.4

Apiggahaṇena nipātapayogepi pañcamīvibhatti hoti dutiyā ca tatiyā ca. Rahitā mātujā puññaṃ katvā dānaṃ deti, rahitā mātujaṃ, rahitā mātujena vā. Rite saddhammā kuto sukhaṃ labhati, rite saddhammaṃ, rite saddhammena vā. Te bhikkhū nānā kulā pabbajitā, vinā saddhammā natthañño koci nātho loke vijjati, vinā saddhammaṃ, vinā saddhammena vā. Vinā buddhasmā, vinā buddhaṃ, vinā buddhena vā.

By the mention of api (“also”), the fifth inflection ⑤ is used in construction with a particle (nipāta) too, and so are the second ② and the third ③.5

Caggahaṇena aññatthāpi pañcamīvibhatti hoti. Yatohaṃ bhagini ariyāya jātiyā jāto. Yato sarāmi attānaṃ, yato pattosmi viññutaṃ, yatvādhikaraṇamenaṃ cakkhundriyaṃ asaṃvutaṃ viharantaṃ abhijjhādomanassā pāpakā akusalā dhammā anvāsaveyyuṃ.

By the mention of ca (“and”), the fifth inflection ⑤ is used elsewhere as well.


§273 (310): Rakkhaṇatthānamicchitaṃ (with verbs of guarding, the thing one wants kept safe) anvattha

Section titled “§273 (310): Rakkhaṇatthānamicchitaṃ (with verbs of guarding, the thing one wants kept safe) anvattha ”

Rakkhaṇatthānaṃ dhātūnaṃ payoge yaṃ icchitaṃ, taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Kāke rakkhanti taṇḍulā, yavā paṭisedhenti gāvo.

In construction with roots in the sense of guarding, the kāraka that is wanted (icchita) is termed apādāna.


§274 (311): Yena vā’ dassanaṃ (optionally, the one from whose sight one hides) anvattha

Section titled “§274 (311): Yena vā’ dassanaṃ (optionally, the one from whose sight one hides) anvattha ”

Yena vā adassanamicchitaṃ, taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Upajjhāyā antaradhāyati sisso, mātarā ca pitarā ca antaradhāyati putto.

Vāti kimatthaṃ? Sattamīvibhatyatthaṃ6. Jetavane antaradhāyati bhagavā.

Optionally, the kāraka by whom one wishes not to be seen is termed apādāna.


§275 (312): Dūranti kaddha kāla nimmāna tvālopa disāyogavibhattārappayoga suddhappamocana hetu vivittappamāṇa pubbayogabandhana guṇavacana pañha kathana thokākattūsu ca (and in twenty further senses, from distance to non-agency) anvattha

Section titled “§275 (312): Dūranti kaddha kāla nimmāna tvālopa disāyogavibhattārappayoga suddhappamocana hetu vivittappamāṇa pubbayogabandhana guṇavacana pañha kathana thokākattūsu ca (and in twenty further senses, from distance to non-agency) anvattha ”

Dūratthe, antikatthe, addhanimmāne, kālanimmāne, tvālope, disāyoge, vibhatte, ārappayoge, suddhe, pamocane, hetvatthe, vivittatthe, pamāṇe, pubbayoge, bandhanatthe, guṇavacane, pañhe, kathane, thoke, akattari ca iccetesvatthesu, payogesu ca, taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

In the senses of distance, nearness, a measure of distance, a measure of time7, an elided tvā, connection with a direction, distinction, construction with [words of] abstaining, purity, release, cause, seclusion, extent, connection with pubba, bondage, the statement of a quality, a question, telling, a little, and a non-agent — in these senses and constructions too, that kāraka is termed apādāna.

Dūratthetāva – kīva dūro ito naḷakāragāmo, dūrato vā gamma, ārakā te moghapurisā imasmā dhammavinayā. Dutiyā ca tatiyā ca, dūraṃ gāmaṃ āgato8, dūrena gāmena vā āgato. Ārakā imaṃ dhammavinayaṃ, anena dhammavinayena vā iccevamādi.

Antikatthe – antikaṃ gāmā, āsannaṃ gāmā, samīpaṃ gāmā, samīpaṃ saddhammā. Dutiyā ca tatiyā ca, antikaṃ gāmaṃ, antikaṃ gāmena vā. Āsannaṃ gāmaṃ, āsannaṃ gāmena vā. Samīpaṃ gāmaṃ. Samīpaṃ gāmena vā. Samīpaṃ saddhammaṃ, samīpaṃ saddhammena vā iccevamādi.

Addhanimmāne – ito mathurāya catūsu yojanesu saṅkassaṃ nāma nagaraṃ atthi, tattha bahū janā vasanti iccevamādi.

Kālanimmāne – ito bhikkhave ekanavutikappe vipassī nāma bhagavā loke udapādi, ito tiṇṇaṃ māsānaṃ accayena parinibbāyissati iccevamādi.

Tvālope kammādhikaraṇesu – pāsādā saṅkameyya, pāsādaṃ abhiruhitvā vā. Pabbatā saṅkameyya, pabbataṃ abhiruhitvā vā. Hatthikkhandhā saṅkameyya, hatthikkhandhaṃ abhiruhitvā vā. Āsanā vuṭṭhaheyya. Āsane nisīditvā vā iccevamādi.

Disāyoge – avīcito9 yāva uparibhavaggamantare bahū sattanikāyā vasanti, yato khemaṃ tato bhayaṃ, puratthimato, dakkhiṇato, pacchimato, uttarato aggī pajjalanti, yato assosuṃ bhagavantaṃ, uddhaṃ pādatalā adho kesamatthakā iccevamādi.

Vibhatte – yato paṇītataro vā visiṭṭhataro vā natthi. Chaṭṭhī ca, channavutīnaṃ pāsaṇḍānaṃ, dhammānaṃ pavaraṃ yadidaṃ sugatavinayo iccevamādi.

Ārappayoge – gāmadhammā vasaladhammā asaddhammā ārati virati paṭivirati, pāṇātipātā veramaṇī iccevamādi.

Suddhe – lobhaniyehi dhammehi suddho asaṃsaṭṭho, mātito ca pitito ca suddho asaṃsaṭṭho anupakuddho agarahito iccevamādi.

Pamocane – parimutto dukkhasmāti vadāmi, muttosmi mārabandhanā, na te muccanti maccunā iccevamādi.

Hetvatthe – kasmā hetunā, kena hetunā, kissa hetunā, kasmā nu tumhaṃ daharā na mīyare, kasmā idheva maraṇaṃ bhavissati iccevamādi.

Vivittatthe – vivitto pāpakā dhammā, vivicceva kāmehi vivicca akusalehi dhammehi iccevamādi.

Pamāṇe – dīghaso navavidatthiyo sugatavidatthiyā pamāṇikā kāretabbā, majjhimassa purisassa aḍḍha teḷasahatthā iccevamādi.

Pubbayoge – pubbeva sambodhā10 iccevamādi.

Bandhanatthe – satasmā bandho11 naro. Tatiyā ca, satena bandho naro raññā iṇatthena iccevamādi.

Guṇavacane – puññāya sugatiṃ yanti, cāgāya vipulaṃ dhanaṃ, paññāya vimuttimano, issariyāya janaṃ rakkhati rājā iccevamādi.

Pañhe tvālope kammādhikaraṇesu – abhidhammā pucchanti, abhidhammaṃ sutvā, abhidhamme ṭhatvā vā. Vinayā pucchanti, vinayaṃ sutvā, vinaye ṭhatvā vā. Dutiyā ca tatiyā ca, abhidhammaṃ, abhidhammena vā. Vinayaṃ, vinayena vā. Evaṃ12 suttā, geyyā, gāthāya, veyyākaraṇā, udānā, itivuttakā, jātakā, abbhutadhammā, vedallā iccevamādi.

Kathane tvālope kammādhikaraṇesu – abhidhammā kathayanti, abhidhammaṃ sutvā, abhidhamme ṭhatvā vā. Vinayā kathayanti, vinayaṃ sutvā, vinaye ṭhatvā vā. Dutiyā ca tatiyā ca, abhidhammaṃ, abhidhammena vā. Vinayaṃ vinayena vā. Evaṃ suttā, geyyā, gāthāya, veyyākaraṇā, udānā, itivuttakā, jātakā, abbhutadhammā, vedallā iccevamādi.

Thoke – thokā muccanti. Appamattakā muccanti, kicchā muccanti. Tatiyā ca. Thokena, appamattakena, kicchena vā iccevamādi.

Akattarica – kammassa katattā upacitattā ussannattā vipulattā cakkhuviññāṇaṃ uppannaṃ hoti iccevamādi.

Caggahaṇena sesesupi ye mayā nopadiṭṭhā apādānapayogikā, te payogavicakkhaṇehi yathāyogaṃ yojetabbā.

By the mention of ca (“and”), in the remaining instances too, the apādāna constructions that I have not pointed out are to be applied, as applicable, by those who are discerning in usage.


§276 (302): Yassa dātukāmo rocate dhārayate vā taṃ sampadānaṃ (the one to whom one wishes to give, to whom [something] is pleasing, or to whom one owes: sampadāna) anvattha

Section titled “§276 (302): Yassa dātukāmo rocate dhārayate vā taṃ sampadānaṃ (the one to whom one wishes to give, to whom [something] is pleasing, or to whom one owes: sampadāna) anvattha ”

Yassa vā dātukāmo yassa vārocate, yassa vā dhārayate, taṃ kārakaṃ sampadānasaññaṃ hoti.

Samaṇassa cīvaraṃ dadāti, samaṇassa rocate saccaṃ, devadattassa suvaṇṇacchattaṃ dhārayate yaññadatto.

Sampadānamiccanena kvattho? Sampadāne catutthī.

Vāti vikappanatthaṃ, dhātunāmānaṃ payoge vā upasaggappayoge vā nipātappayoge vā sati atthavikappanatthaṃ vāti padaṃ payujjati.

The kāraka to whom one wishes to give, to whom [something] is pleasing, or to whom one owes16 is termed sampadāna (the recipient).

Vā is there for the sake of an option (vikappana): where there is a construction with roots and nouns, with prefixes or with particles, the word vā is employed for the sake of an alternative sense (atthavikappana).


§277 (303): Silāgha hanu ṭhā sapa dhāra piha kudha duhisso ssūya rādhikkha paccāsuṇa anupatigiṇa pubbakattārocanattha tadattha tumatthālamattha maññānādarappāṇini gatyatthakammaniāsisatthasammutibhiyyasattamyatthesu ca (and twenty-odd further constructions that take the term sampadāna) anvattha

Section titled “§277 (303): Silāgha hanu ṭhā sapa dhāra piha kudha duhisso ssūya rādhikkha paccāsuṇa anupatigiṇa pubbakattārocanattha tadattha tumatthālamattha maññānādarappāṇini gatyatthakammaniāsisatthasammutibhiyyasattamyatthesu ca (and twenty-odd further constructions that take the term sampadāna) anvattha ”

Silāgha hanu ṭhā sapa dhāra piha kudha duha issaiccetesaṃ dhātūnaṃ payoge, usūyatthānañca payoge, rādhikkhappayoge, paccāsuṇaanupatigiṇānaṃ pubbakattari, ārocanatthe, tadatthe, tumatthe, alamatthe, maññatippayoge anādare appāṇini, gatyatthānaṃ dhātūnaṃ kammani, āsīsatthe ca sammuti bhiyya sattamyatthesu ca, taṃ kārakaṃ sampadānasaññaṃ hoti.

That kāraka is termed sampadāna also in construction with the roots silāgha, hanu, ṭhā, sapa, dhāra, piha, kudha, duha and issa, and with roots in the sense of usūya (envy); in construction with rādha and ikkha; as the prior agent of paccāsuṇa and anupatigiṇa; in the sense of announcing; in the sense of purpose (tadattha); in the sense of an infinitive (tumattha); in the sense of alaṃ; in construction with maññati, in contempt and regarding an inanimate thing; as the object of roots in the sense of going; in the sense of wishing well; and in construction with sammuti and bhiyya, and in the sense of the seventh ⑦.

Silāghappayoge tāva – buddhassa silāghate, dhammassa silāghate, saṅghassa silāghate, sakaupajjhāyassa17 silāghate, tava silāghate mama silāghate iccevamādi.

Hanuppayoge – hanute tuyhameva, hanute mayhameva iccevamādi.

Ṭhāpayoge – upatiṭṭheyya sakyaputtānaṃ vaḍḍhakī, bhikkhussa bhuñjantassa pānīyena vā vidhūpanena vā upatiṭṭheyya bhikkhunī iccevamādi.

Sapappayoge – tuyhaṃ sapate, mayhaṃ sapate iccevamādi.

Dhārappayoge – suvaṇṇaṃ te dhārayate iccevamādi.

Pihappayoge – buddhassa aññatitthiyā pihayanti, devā dassanakāmā te, yato icchāmi bhaddantassa, samiddhānaṃ pihayanti daliddā iccevamādi.

Kudhaduhaissausūyappayoge – kodhayati deva dattassa, tassa kujjha mahāvīra, mā raṭṭhaṃ vinassa idaṃ. Duhayati disānaṃ megho, titthiyā samaṇānaṃ issayanti guṇagiddhena, titthiyā samaṇānaṃ issayanti lābhagiddhena, dujjanā guṇavantānaṃ usūyanti guṇagiddhena, kā usūyā vijānataṃ iccevamādi.

Rādha ikkha iccetesaṃ dhātūnaṃ payoge yassa akathitassa pucchanaṃ kammavikkhyāpanatthañca, taṃ kārakaṃ sampadānasaññaṃ hoti, dutiyā ca.

Ārādhohaṃ rañño, ārādhohaṃ rājānaṃ, kyāhaṃ ayyānaṃ aparajjhāmi, kyāhaṃ ayye aparajjhāmi, cakkhuṃ janassa dassanāya taṃ viya maññe, āyasmato upālittherassa upasampadāpekkho upatisso, āyasmantaṃ vā iccevamādi.

In construction with the roots rādha and ikkha, the unstated one about whom there is enquiry, and for the sake of making the action known — that kāraka is termed sampadāna, and the second form ② as well.18

Paccāsuṇa anupatigiṇānaṃ pubbakattari suṇotissa paccāyoge yassa kammuno pubbassa yo kattā, so sampadānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Bhagavā bhikkhū etadavoca.

Bhikkhūti akathitakammaṃ19, etanti kathitakammaṃ. Yassa kammuno pubbassa yo kattā, so‘bhagavā’ti ‘‘yo karoti sa kattā’’ti suttavacanena kattusañño. Evaṃ yassa kammuno pubbassa yo kattā, so sampadānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Te bhikkhū bhagavato paccassosuṃ, āsuṇanti buddhassa bhikkhū.

Giṇassa anupatiyoge yassa kammuno pubbassa yo kattā, so sampadānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Bhikkhu janaṃ dhammaṃ sāveti, tassa bhikkhuno jano anugiṇāti, tassa bhikkhuno jano patigiṇāti.

Yo vadeti sa‘kattā’ti,
Vuttaṃ ‘kamma’nti vuccati;
Yo paṭiggāhako tassa,
‘Sampadānaṃ’ vijāniyā.

Iccevamādi.

As the prior agent of paccāsuṇa and anupatigiṇa: in the construction of suṇoti with pati and ā, the agent of the prior action is termed sampadāna. bhikkhū is the unstated object (akathitakamma) and etaṃ the stated object (kathitakamma); the agent of the prior action, bhagavā, is termed kattā by the wording of the sutta §281 (294): Yo karoti sa kattā, and so the agent of the prior action is termed sampadāna. In the construction of giṇa with anu and pati, the agent of the prior action is termed sampadāna.

The one who speaks is the kattā,
what is spoken is called the kamma,
and the one who receives it
one should know as the sampadāna.

And so on.

Ārocanatthe – ārocayāmi vo bhikkhave, āmantayāmi vo bhikkhave, paṭivedayāmi vo bhikkhave, ārocayāmi te mahārāja, āmantayāmi te mahārāja, paṭivedayāmi te mahārāja iccevamādi.

Tadatthe – ūnassa pāripūriyā taṃ cīvaraṃ nikkhipitabbaṃ. Buddhassa atthāya, dhammassa atthāya, saṅghassa atthāya, jīvitaṃ pariccajāmi iccevamādi.

Tumatthe -lokānukampāya atthāya hitāya sukhāya devamanussānaṃ buddho loke uppajjati. Bhikkhūnaṃ phāsuvihārāya vinayo paññatto iccevamādi.

Alamatthappayoge-alamiti arahati paṭikkhittesu. Alaṃ me buddho, alaṃ me rajjaṃ, alaṃ bhikkhu pattassa, alaṃ mallo mallassa, arahati mallo mallassa. Paṭikkhitte alaṃ te rūpaṃ karaṇīyaṃ, alaṃ me hiraññasuvaṇṇena iccevamādi.

Maññatippayoge anādare appāṇini-kaṭṭhassa tuvaṃ maññe, kaliṅgarassa tuvaṃ maññe.

Anādareti kimatthaṃ? Suvaṇṇaṃ viya taṃ maññe.

Appāṇinīti kimatthaṃ? Gadrabhaṃ tuvaṃ maññe iccevamādi.

Gatyatthakammani-gāmassa pādena gato, nagarassa pādena gato, appo saggāya gacchati, saggassa gamanena vā, mūlāya paṭikasseyya saṅgho. Dutiyā ca, gāmaṃ pādena gato, nagaraṃ pādena gato, appo saggaṃ gacchati, saggaṃ gamanena vā, mūlaṃ paṭikasseyya saṅgho iccevamādi.

Āsīsatthe-āyasmato dīghāyuko hotu, bhaddaṃ bhavato hotu, kusalaṃ bhavato hotu, anāmayaṃ bhavato hotu, sukhaṃ bhavato hotu, svāgataṃ bhavato hotu, attho bhavato hotu, hitaṃ bhavato hotu iccevamādi.

Sammutippayoge– aññatra saṅghasammutiyā bhikkhussa vippavatthuṃ na vaṭṭati, sādhu sammuti me tassa bhagavato dassanāya iccevamādi.

Bhiyyappayoge – bhiyyoso mattāya22 iccevamādi.

Sattamyatthe – tuyhañcassa āvi karomi, tassa me sakko pāturahosi iccevamādi.

Atthaggahaṇena bahūsu akkharappayogesu dissati.

Taṃ yathā? Upamaṃ te23 karissāmi, dhammaṃ vo desessāmi.

Sāratthe ca – desetu bhante bhagavā dhammaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ. Tassa phāsu vihārāya hoti, etassa pahiṇeyya, yathā no bhagavā byākareyya, tathāpi tesaṃ byākarissāma, kappati samaṇānaṃ āyogo, amhākaṃ maṇinā attho, kimattho me buddhena, seyyo me attho, bahūpakārā bhante mahāpajā patigotamī bhagavato, bahūpakārā bhikkhave mātāpitaro puttānaṃ iccevamādi.

Sesesu akkharappayogesupi aññepi payogā payogavicakkhaṇehi yojetabbā.

By the mention of attha (“sense”), [the fourth form ④] is seen in many constructions of words. And in the essential sense (sārattha)24. In the remaining constructions of words as well, other usages too are to be applied by those who are discerning in usage.

Caggahaṇaṃ vikappanatthavāggahaṇānukaḍḍhanatthaṃ. Ye keci saddā sampadānappayogikā mayā nopadiṭṭhā, tesaṃ gahaṇatthaṃ idha vikappīyati vāsaddo.

Taṃ yathā? Bhikkhusaṅghassa pabhū ayaṃ bhagavā, desassa pabhū ayaṃ rājā. Khettassa pabhū ayaṃ gahapati, araññassa pabhū ayaṃ luddako iccevamādi. Kvaci dutiyā tatiyā pañcamī25 chaṭṭhī sattamyatthesu ca.

The mention of ca is there to draw along (anukaḍḍhana) the mention of vā in the sense of an option: the word vā is applied here as an option so as to take in whatever words in a sampadāna construction I have not pointed out. And in some places [the fourth form ④ stands] in the senses of the second ②, the third ③, the fifth ⑤, the sixth ⑥ and the seventh ⑦.


§278 (320): Yodhāro tamokāsaṃ (the support of the action: okāsa) anvattha

Section titled “§278 (320): Yodhāro tamokāsaṃ (the support of the action: okāsa) anvattha ”

Yo ādhāro, taṃ okāsasaññaṃ hoti. Svādhāro catubbidho byāpiko, opasilesiko, vesayiko sāmīpiko cāti.

Tattha byāpiko tāva–jalesu khīraṃ tiṭṭhati, tilesu telaṃ, ucchūsu raso.

Opasilesiko–pariyaṅke rājā seti, āsane upaviṭṭho saṅgho.

Vesayiko–bhūmīsu manussā caranti, antalikkhe vāyū vāyanti. Ākāse sakuṇā pakkhandanti.

Sāmīpiko–vane hatthino caranti, gaṅgāyaṃ ghoso tiṭṭhati, vaje gāvo duhanti, sāvatthiyaṃ viharati jetavane.

Okāsamiccanena kvattho? Okāse sattamī.

That which is the support (ādhāra) is termed okāsa (the location). That support is of four kinds: pervading (byāpika), by contact (opasilesika), by domain (vesayika) and by proximity (sāmīpika).


§279 (292): Yena vā kayirate taṃ karaṇaṃ (that by which [the action] is done: karaṇa) anvattha

Section titled “§279 (292): Yena vā kayirate taṃ karaṇaṃ (that by which [the action] is done: karaṇa) anvattha ”

Yena vā kayirate, yena vā passati, yena vā suṇāti, taṃ kārakaṃ karaṇasaññaṃ hoti.

Dattena vīhiṃ26 lunāti, vāsiyā kaṭṭhaṃ tacchati, pharasunā rukkhaṃ chindati, kudālena pathaviṃ27 khaṇati, satthena kammaṃ karoti. Cakkhunā rūpaṃ passati, sotena saddaṃ suṇāti28.

Karaṇamiccanena kvattho? Karaṇe tatiyā.

The kāraka by which [something] is done, or by which one sees or hears, is termed karaṇa (the instrument).


§280 (285): Yaṃ karoti taṃ kammaṃ (what one does: kamma) anvattha

Section titled “§280 (285): Yaṃ karoti taṃ kammaṃ (what one does: kamma) anvattha ”

Yaṃ vā karoti, yaṃ vā passati, yaṃ vā suṇāti, taṃ kārakaṃ kammasaññaṃ hoti.

Chattaṃ karoti, rathaṃ karoti, rūpaṃ passati, saddaṃ suṇāti, kaṇṭakaṃ maddati, visaṃ gilati.

Kammamiccanena kvattho? Kammatthe dutiyā.

Whatever one does, sees or hears — that kāraka is termed kamma (the object).


§281 (294): Yo karoti sa kattā (the one who does: kattā) anvattha

Section titled “§281 (294): Yo karoti sa kattā (the one who does: kattā) anvattha ”

Yo karoti, so kattusañño hoti.

Ahinā daṭṭho naro, garuḷena hato nāgo. Buddhena jito māro, upaguttena māro bandho29.

Kattuiccanena kvattho? Kattari ca.

The one who acts is termed kattā (the agent).


§282 (295): Yo kāreti sa hetu (the one who makes [the agent] act: hetu) anvattha

Section titled “§282 (295): Yo kāreti sa hetu (the one who makes [the agent] act: hetu) anvattha ”

Yo kattāraṃ kāreti, so hetusañño hoti, kattā ca.

So puriso taṃ purisaṃ kammaṃ kāreti so puriso tena purisena kammaṃ kāreti, so puriso tassa purisassa kammaṃ kāreti. Evaṃ hāreti pāṭheti pāceti, dhāreti.

Hetuiccanena kvattho? Dhātūhi ṇe ṇaya ṇāpe ṇāpayā kāritāni hetvatthe.

The one who makes the agent act is termed hetu (the causer), and kattā as well.


§283 (316): Yassa vā pariggaho taṃ sāmī (one who has a possession: sāmī) anvattha

Section titled “§283 (316): Yassa vā pariggaho taṃ sāmī (one who has a possession: sāmī) anvattha ”

Yassa vā pariggaho, taṃ sāmīsaññaṃ hoti.

Tassa bhikkhuno paṭivīso, tassa bhikkhuno patto, tassa bhikkhuno cīvaraṃ, attano mukhaṃ.

Sāmīiccanena kvattho? Sāmismiṃ chaṭṭhī.

Optionally, one who has a possession (pariggaha) is termed sāmī (the owner).30


§284 (283): Liṅgatthe paṭhamā (the first form ① for the bare meaning of the lemma) utsarga

Section titled “§284 (283): Liṅgatthe paṭhamā (the first form ① for the bare meaning of the lemma) utsarga ”

Liṅgatthābhidhānamatte paṭhamāvibhatti hoti.

Puriso, purisā, eko, dve, ca, vā, he, ahe, re, are.

The first inflection ① is used merely to express the meaning of the lemma (liṅgattha).31


§285 (70): Ālapane ca (and in the vocative ⓪) utsarga

Section titled “§285 (70): Ālapane ca (and in the vocative ⓪) utsarga ”

Ālapanatthā dhike liṅgatthābhidhānamatte ca paṭhamāvibhatti hoti.

Bho purisa, bhavanto purisā, bho rāja, bhavanto rājāno, he sakhe, he sakhino.

The first inflection ① is used also when the sense of the vocative (ālapana) is added to the mere expression of the meaning of the lemma.32


§286 (291): Karaṇe tatiyā (the third form ③ for the instrument) utsarga

Section titled “§286 (291): Karaṇe tatiyā (the third form ③ for the instrument) utsarga ”

Karaṇakārake tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Agginā kuṭiṃ jhāpeti, manasā ce paduṭṭhena, manasā ce pasannena, kāyena kammaṃ karoti.

The third inflection ③ is used for the instrument (karaṇa) kāraka.


§287 (296): Sahādiyoge ca (and in construction with saha and the like) apavada

Section titled “§287 (296): Sahādiyoge ca (and in construction with saha and the like) apavada ”

Sahādiyogatthe ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Sahāpi gaggena saṅgho uposathaṃ kareyya, vināpi gaggena, mahatā bhikkhusaṅghena saddhiṃ, sahassena samaṃ mitā.

The third inflection ③ is also used in the sense of construction with saha and the like.


§288 (293): Kattari ca (and for the agent) utsarga

Section titled “§288 (293): Kattari ca (and for the agent) utsarga ”

Kattari ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Raññā hato poso, yakkhena dinno varo, ahinā daṭṭho naro.

The third inflection ③ is also used for the agent (kattā).


§289 (297): Hetvatthe ca (and in the sense of cause) apavada

Section titled “§289 (297): Hetvatthe ca (and in the sense of cause) apavada ”

Hetvatthe ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Annena vasati, dhammena vasati, vijjāya vasati, sakkārena vasati.

The third inflection ③ is also used in the sense of cause (hetu).


§290 (298): Sattamyatthe ca (and in the sense of the seventh) apavada

Section titled “§290 (298): Sattamyatthe ca (and in the sense of the seventh) apavada ”

Sattamyatthe ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Tena kālena, tena samayena. (Yena kālena, yena samayena,) tena kho pana samayena.

The third inflection ③ is also used in the sense of the seventh ⑦.33


§291 (299): Yenaṅgavikāro (the limb by which a bodily defect is marked) apavada

Section titled “§291 (299): Yenaṅgavikāro (the limb by which a bodily defect is marked) apavada ”

Yena byādhimatā aṅgena aṅgino vikāro lakkhīyate. Tattha tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Akkhinā kāṇo, hatthena kuṇī, kāṇaṃ passati nettena, pādena khañjo, piṭṭhiyā khujjo.

The third inflection ③ is used for the diseased limb by which the defect of the one who has the limb is marked.34


§292 (300): Visesane ca (and for the distinguishing attribute) apavada

Section titled “§292 (300): Visesane ca (and for the distinguishing attribute) apavada ”

Visesanatthe ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Gottena gotamo nātho, suvaṇṇena abhirūpo, tapasā uttamo.

The third inflection ③ is also used in the sense of a distinguishing attribute (visesana).


§293 (85, 301): Sampadāne catutthī (④ for the sampadāna [recipient]) utsarga

Section titled “§293 (85, 301): Sampadāne catutthī (④ for the sampadāna [recipient]) utsarga ”

Sampadānakārake catutthīvibhatti hoti.

Buddhassa vā dhammassa vā saṅghassa vā dānaṃ deti, dātā hoti samaṇassa vā brāhmaṇassa vā.

The fourth inflection ④ is used for the recipient (sampadāna) kāraka.


§294 (305): Namoyogādīsvapi ca (and ④ in construction with namo and the like) apavada

Section titled “§294 (305): Namoyogādīsvapi ca (and ④ in construction with namo and the like) apavada ”

Namoyogādīsvapi ca catutthīvibhatti hoti.

Namo te buddha vīratthu, sotthi pajānaṃ, namo karohi nāgassa, svāgataṃ te mahārāja.

And the fourth inflection ④ is also used in construction with namo and the like.


§295 (307): Apādāne pañcamī (⑤ for the apādāna [point of departure]) utsarga

Section titled “§295 (307): Apādāne pañcamī (⑤ for the apādāna [point of departure]) utsarga ”

Apādānakārake pañcamīvibhatti hoti.

Pāpā cittaṃ nivāraye, abbhā muttova candimā, bhayā muccati so naro.

The fifth inflection ⑤ is used for the point of departure (apādāna) kāraka.


§296 (314): Kāraṇatthe ca (and ⑤ in the sense of cause) apavada

Section titled “§296 (314): Kāraṇatthe ca (and ⑤ in the sense of cause) apavada ”

Kāraṇatthe ca pañcamīvibhatti hoti.

Ananubodhā appaṭivedhā catunnaṃ ariyasaccānaṃ yathābhūtaṃ adassanā.

The fifth inflection ⑤ is also used in the sense of cause (kāraṇa).


§297 (284): Kammatthe dutiyā (② for the kamma [object]) utsarga

Section titled “§297 (284): Kammatthe dutiyā (② for the kamma [object]) utsarga ”

Kammatthe dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Gāvaṃ hanati35, vīhayo lunāti, satthaṃ karoti, ghaṭaṃ karoti, rathaṃ karoti, dhammaṃ suṇāti, buddhaṃ pūjeti, vācaṃ bhāsati36, taṇḍulaṃ pacati37, coraṃ ghāteti.

The second inflection ② is used in the sense of the object (kamma).


§298 (287): Kāladdhānamaccantasaṃyoge (② for time and distance in unbroken connection) apavada

Section titled “§298 (287): Kāladdhānamaccantasaṃyoge (② for time and distance in unbroken connection) apavada ”

Kāladdhānaṃ accantasaṃyoge dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Māsaṃ maṃsodanaṃ bhuñjati, saradaṃ ramaṇīyā nadī, māsaṃ sajjhāyati, yojanaṃ vanarāji, yojanaṃ dīgho pabbato, kosaṃ sajjhāyati.

Accantasaṃyogeti kimatthaṃ?

Saṃvacchare bhojanaṃ bhuñjati.

The second inflection ② is used after [words of] time and distance in unbroken connection (accantasaṃyoga).38


§299 (288): Kammappavacanīyayutte (② with a kammappavacanīya [governing particle]) apavada

Section titled “§299 (288): Kammappavacanīyayutte (② with a kammappavacanīya [governing particle]) apavada ”

Kammappavacanīyayutte dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Taṃ kho pana bhavantaṃ gotamaṃ evaṃ kalyāṇo kittisaddo abbhuggato, pabbajitamanupabbajiṃsu.

The second inflection ② is used in construction with a kammappavacanīya.


§300 (286): Gati buddhi bhuja paṭha hara kara sayādīnaṃ kārite vā (optionally ② for the one made to act in a causative) apavada

Section titled “§300 (286): Gati buddhi bhuja paṭha hara kara sayādīnaṃ kārite vā (optionally ② for the one made to act in a causative) apavada ”

Gati buddhi bhuja paṭha hara kara sayādīnaṃ payoge kārite dutiyāvibhatti hoti vā.

Puriso purisaṃ (gāmaṃ) gāmayati, puriso purisena vā, puriso purisassa vā. Evaṃ bodhayati, bhojayati, pāṭhayati, hārayati, kārayati, sayāpayati. Evaṃ sabbattha kārite.

In the causative (kārita), the second inflection ② is optionally used in construction with [roots meaning] going, knowing, eating, reciting, carrying, doing, lying down and the like.


§301 (315): Sāmismiṃ chaṭṭhī (⑥ for the sāmī [owner]) utsarga

Section titled “§301 (315): Sāmismiṃ chaṭṭhī (⑥ for the sāmī [owner]) utsarga ”

Sāmismiṃ chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti.

Tassa bhikkhuno paṭivīso, tassa bhikkhuno patto, tassa bhikkhuno cīvaraṃ, attano mukhaṃ.

The sixth inflection ⑥ is used for the owner (sāmī).


§302 (319): Okāse sattamī (⑦ for the okāsa [location]) utsarga

Section titled “§302 (319): Okāse sattamī (⑦ for the okāsa [location]) utsarga ”

Okāsakārake sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Gambhīre odakantike, pāpasmiṃ ramati mano, bhagavati brahmacariyaṃ vussati kulaputto.

The seventh inflection ⑦ is used for the location (okāsa) kāraka.


§303 (321): Sāmissarādhipati dāyāda sakkhīpatibhū pasutakusalehi ca (⑥, and ⑦, with owner, lord, chief, heir, witness, surety, intent, skilled) apavada

Section titled “§303 (321): Sāmissarādhipati dāyāda sakkhīpatibhū pasutakusalehi ca (⑥, and ⑦, with owner, lord, chief, heir, witness, surety, intent, skilled) apavada ”

Sāmī issara adhipati dāyāda sakkhīpatibhū pasutakusala iccetehi payoge chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti, sattamī ca.

Goṇānaṃ sāmī, goṇesu sāmī, goṇānaṃ issaro, goṇesu issaro. Goṇānaṃ adhipati, goṇesu adhipati. Goṇānaṃ dāyādo, goṇesu dāyādo. Goṇānaṃ sakkhī, goṇesu sakkhī, goṇānaṃ patibhū, goṇesu patibhū. Goṇānaṃ pasuto, goṇesu pasuto. Goṇānaṃ kusalo, goṇesu kusalo.

In construction with sāmī (owner), issara (lord), adhipati (chief), dāyāda (heir), sakkhī (witness), patibhū (surety), pasuta (intent on) and kusala (skilled), the sixth inflection ⑥ is used, and the seventh ⑦ as well.41


§304 (322): Niddhāraṇe ca (and ⑥, ⑦ for the group one is singled out from) apavada

Section titled “§304 (322): Niddhāraṇe ca (and ⑥, ⑦ for the group one is singled out from) apavada ”

Niddhāraṇatthe ca chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti, sattamī ca.

Kaṇhā gāvīnaṃ sampannakhīratamā, kaṇhā gāvīsu sampannakhīratamā. Sāmā nārīnaṃ dassanīyatamā, sāmā nārīsu dassanīyatamā. Manussānaṃ khattiyo sūratamo, manussesu khattiyo sūratamo. Pathikānaṃ dhāvanto sīghatamo, pathikesu dhāvanto sīghatamo.

And in the sense of singling out (niddhāraṇa) the sixth inflection ⑥ is used, and the seventh ⑦ as well.


§305 (323): Anādare ca (and ⑥, ⑦ for what is disregarded) apavada

Section titled “§305 (323): Anādare ca (and ⑥, ⑦ for what is disregarded) apavada ”

Anādare chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti, sattamī ca.

Rudato dārakassa pabbaji, rudantasmiṃ dārake pabbaji.

For disregard (anādara) the sixth inflection ⑥ is used, and the seventh ⑦ as well.


§306 (289): Kvaci dutiyā chaṭṭhīnamatthe (sometimes ② in the sense of the sixth) apavada

Section titled “§306 (289): Kvaci dutiyā chaṭṭhīnamatthe (sometimes ② in the sense of the sixth) apavada ”

Chaṭṭhīnamatthe kvaci dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Apissu maṃ aggivessana tisso upamā paṭibhaṃsu.

In some places the second inflection ② is used in the sense of the sixth ⑥.


§307 (290): Tatiyāsattamīnañca (and [sometimes ②] in the sense of the third and seventh) apavada

Section titled “§307 (290): Tatiyāsattamīnañca (and [sometimes ②] in the sense of the third and seventh) apavada ”

Tatiyāsattamīnaṃ atthe ca kvaci dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Sace maṃ samaṇo gotamo ālapissati, tvañca maṃ nābhibhāsasi. Evaṃ tatiyatthe.

Pubbaṇhasamayaṃ nivāsetvā, ekaṃ samayaṃ bhagavā. Evaṃ sattamyatthe.

And in some places the second inflection ② is used in the sense of the third ③ and the seventh ⑦.


§308 (317): Chaṭṭhī ca (and [sometimes] ⑥ in the sense of the third and seventh) apavada

Section titled “§308 (317): Chaṭṭhī ca (and [sometimes] ⑥ in the sense of the third and seventh) apavada ”

Tatiyāsattamīnaṃ atthe ca kvaci chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti.

Kato me kalyāṇo, kataṃ me pāpaṃ. Evaṃ tatiyatthe.

Kusalā naccagītassa sikkhitā cāturitthiyo, kusalo tvaṃ rathassa aṅgapaccaṅgānaṃ. Evaṃ sattamyatthe.

Kvacīti kimatthaṃ?

Yo vo ānanda mayā dhammo ca vinayo ca desito paññatto, ānando atthesu vicakkhaṇo.

And in some places the sixth inflection ⑥ is used in the sense of the third ③ and the seventh ⑦.


§309 (318): Dutiyāpañcamīnañca (and [sometimes ⑥] in the sense of the second and fifth) apavada

Section titled “§309 (318): Dutiyāpañcamīnañca (and [sometimes ⑥] in the sense of the second and fifth) apavada ”

Dutiyāpañcamīnañca atthe kvaci chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti.

Tassa bhavanti vattāro, sahasā kammassa kattāro, evaṃ dutiyatthe.

Assavanatā dhammassa parihāyanti, kinnu kho ahaṃ tassa sukhassa bhāyāmi, sabbe tasanti daṇḍassa, sabbe bhāyanti maccuno, bhīto catunnaṃ āsīvisānaṃ ghoravisānaṃ, bhāyāmi ghoravisassa nāgassa. Evaṃ pañcamyatthe.

And in some places the sixth inflection ⑥ is used in the sense of the second ② and the fifth ⑤.42


§310 (324): Kamma karaṇa nimittatthesu sattamī (⑦ in the senses of object, instrument and motive) apavada

Section titled “§310 (324): Kamma karaṇa nimittatthesu sattamī (⑦ in the senses of object, instrument and motive) apavada ”

Kammakaraṇanimittatthesu sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Sundarāvuso ime ājīvakā bhikkhūsu abhivādenti. Evaṃ kammatthe.

Hatthesu piṇḍāya caranti, pattesu piṇḍāya caranti, pathesu gacchanti. Evaṃ karaṇatthe.

Dīpi cammesu haññate, kuñjaro dantesu haññate, evaṃ nimittatthe.

The seventh inflection ⑦ is used in the senses of object (kamma), instrument (karaṇa) and motive (nimitta).


§311 (325): Sampadāne ca (and ⑦ for the sampadāna [recipient]) apavada

Section titled “§311 (325): Sampadāne ca (and ⑦ for the sampadāna [recipient]) apavada ”

Sampadāne ca sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Saṅghe dinnaṃ mahapphalaṃ43, saṅghe gotami44 dehi, saṅghe te dinne ahañceva pūjito bhavissāmi.

The seventh inflection ⑦ is also used for the recipient (sampadāna).


§312 (326): Pañcamyatthe ca (and ⑦ in the sense of the fifth) apavada

Section titled “§312 (326): Pañcamyatthe ca (and ⑦ in the sense of the fifth) apavada ”

Pañcamyatthe ca sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Kadalīsu gaje rakkhanti.

The seventh inflection ⑦ is also used in the sense of the fifth ⑤.


§313 (327): Kālabhāvesu ca (and ⑦ for the time, and the attendant circumstance, of an action) apavada

Section titled “§313 (327): Kālabhāvesu ca (and ⑦ for the time, and the attendant circumstance, of an action) apavada ”

Kālabhāvesu ca kattari payujjamāne sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Pubbaṇhasamaye gato, sāyanhasamaye āgato. Bhikkhūsu bhojīyamānesu gato, bhuttesu āgato. Gosu duyhamānāsu45 gato, duddhāsu āgato.

The seventh inflection ⑦ is also used for time (kāla), and for a state (bhāva) when its agent is expressed.46


§314 (328): Upa’dhyādhikissaravacane (⑦ with upa, adhi in the senses “more than” and “lord over”) apavada

Section titled “§314 (328): Upa’dhyādhikissaravacane (⑦ with upa, adhi in the senses “more than” and “lord over”) apavada ”

Upaadhi iccetesaṃ payoge adhikaissaravacane sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Upa khāriyaṃ doṇo, upa nikkhe kahāpaṇaṃ. Adhi brahmadatte pañcālā, adhi naccesu47 gotamī, adhi devesu buddho.

The seventh inflection ⑦ is used in construction with upa and adhi in the expression of exceeding (adhika) and of lordship (issara).


§315 (329): Maṇḍitussukkesu tatiyā ca (③, and ⑦, in the senses of maṇḍita and ussukka) apavada

Section titled “§315 (329): Maṇḍitussukkesu tatiyā ca (③, and ⑦, in the senses of maṇḍita and ussukka) apavada ”

Maṇḍitaussukka iccetesvatthesu tatiyāvibhatti hoti, sattamī ca.

Ñāṇena pasīdito, ñāṇasmiṃ vā pasīdito, ñāṇena ussukko, ñāṇasmiṃ vā ussukko tathāgato vā tathāgatagotto vā.

In the senses of maṇḍita (gladdened)49 and ussukka (zealous), the third inflection ③ is used, and the seventh ⑦ as well.


Iti nāmakappe kārakakappo chaṭṭho kaṇḍo.

Thus ends the kāraka chapter, the sixth section of the nāma chapter.


Kārakakappo niṭṭhito.

The kāraka chapter is finished.


  1. Senart’s edition, which Malai (1997) prints, adds a fifth example, pāpā cittaṃ nivāraye, between nagarā niggato rājā and corā bhayaṃ jāyate; the CST has four. ↩

  2. CST4 prints upari pabbatā; pari is the reading of B1 and the Rūpasiddhi. ↩

  3. The manuscript B1, as Malai (1997) reports, quotes the canonical yāva brahmalokā for the vutti’s ābrahmalokā; the CST is kept. ↩

  4. Malai (1997) renders kārakamajjhepi “even in the case of other case-relations”; the Pāḷi says “also in the middle of a kāraka”. ↩

  5. Senart’s edition adds nānā kulaṃ, nānā kulena vā after nānā kulā pabbajitā; the manuscripts B1, S1, S2 and the CST omit them. ↩

  6. CST4 prints Sattamīvibhatyattaṃ; Senart’s edition reads Sattamīvibhattyatthaṃ. ↩

  7. Senart’s edition, which Malai (1997) prints, takes addhakālanimmāne as one sense and counts nineteen; the CST’s vutti separates addhanimmāne and kālanimmāne. ↩

  8. CST4 prints āvato; the next clause and the Rūpasiddhi read āgato. ↩

  9. CST4 prints avicito; the Rūpasiddhi reads avīcito. ↩

  10. CST4 prints sammodhā; the canonical phrase is pubbeva sambodhā. ↩

  11. The manuscripts S1 and S2 read baddho for the CST’s bandho, here and at §281 (294): Yo karoti sa kattā; the CST is kept. ↩

  12. CST4 prints Eva suttā; the parallel sentence under Kathane reads Evaṃ suttā. ↩

  13. U Nandisena (2005) renders pubbayoge “in connection with the past”; the Pāḷi says construction with the word pubba, as the example pubbeva sambodhā shows. ↩

  14. Senart’s edition reads paññāya sugatiṃ yanti for the first phrase and issariyā janaṃ rakkhati rājā for the last; the CST is kept. ↩

  15. U Nandisena (2005) glosses akattari “no causative agent”; the Pāḷi says only “non-agent”. ↩

  16. U Nandisena (2005) renders dhārayate “to whom one holds (something for)” and Malai (1997) “one from whom something is borne”; the Pāḷi says “owes”, the creditor being the sampadāna. ↩

  17. CST4 prints sakaṃupajjhāyassa; Senart’s edition reads the compound sakaupajjhāyassa. ↩

  18. U Nandisena (2005) renders akathitassa “the person that does not talk”; the Pāḷi is the participle “not stated”. ↩

  19. CST4 prints akathīta kammaṃ; the Rūpasiddhi and Senart’s edition read akathitakammaṃ. ↩

  20. The comparison to gold is not in contempt, so the rule does not apply. ↩

  21. A donkey is a living being, so the rule does not apply. ↩

  22. CST4 prints mattāyaṃ; the manuscripts B1 and T and the canonical idiom read bhiyyoso mattāya. ↩

  23. CST4 prints Upamaṃ mata karissāmi; Senart’s edition and the canonical phrase read upamaṃ te karissāmi. ↩

  24. Nandisena’s edition records the Sinhalese reading sādaratthe, “in the sense of respect”, for sāratthe; the CST is kept. ↩

  25. Senart’s edition, which Malai (1997) translates, closes Kvaci dutiyā-tatiyā-chaṭṭhī-sattamyatthesu ca, without the CST’s pañcamī. ↩

  26. CST4 prints vihiṃ; the vutti of §297 (284): Kammatthe dutiyā and the Rūpasiddhi spell vīhi. ↩

  27. Nandisena’s edition records the Sinhalese reading kudālena āvāṭaṃ khaṇati; the CST is kept. ↩

  28. CST4 stops the list at cakkhunā rūpaṃ passati; Senart’s and Nandisena’s editions add sotena saddaṃ suṇāti, which is adopted here. ↩

  29. Nandisena’s edition records the variant baddho for the CST’s bandho; the CST is kept. ↩

  30. Malai (1997) reports that the manuscripts T and K carry an extra sutta after this one, Tesaṃ paraṃ ubhayappattimhi, which the Nyāsa calls an interpolation and the CST omits. ↩

  31. U Nandisena (2005) renders liṅgattha “the property of the lemma” and Malai (1997) “the gender”; the Pāḷi says the meaning of the lemma. Senart’s edition lists the particles ca, vā, hi, ahaṃ, hare, are for the CST’s ca, vā, he, ahe, re, are. ↩

  32. Senart’s edition, which Malai (1997) prints, closes the vutti with a sentence the CST lacks, Casaddaggahaṇaṃ paṭhamaggahaṇānukaḍḍhanatthaṃ, and the like at §294 (305): Namoyogādīsvapi ca, §296 (314): Kāraṇatthe ca and §305 (323): Anādare ca. ↩

  33. Nandisena’s edition records that the phrases the CST brackets, yena kālena, yena samayena, are wanting in the Sinhalese text. ↩

  34. U Nandisena (2005) renders kāṇaṃ passati nettena “he sees a person that is blind by eye”, taking kāṇaṃ as the person seen; the gloss above takes it as an adverb. ↩

  35. Senart’s edition, which Malai (1997) prints, runs the list kaṭaṃ karoti, rathaṃ karoti, chattaṃ karoti, dhammaṃ suṇāti …, puts gavaṃ hanati, vīhayo lunāti last and reads gavaṃ for gāvaṃ. ↩

  36. CST4 prints bhāsatī. ↩

  37. CST4 prints vacati; Senart’s and Nandisena’s editions read pacati. ↩

  38. Senart’s edition, which Malai (1997) prints, has the examples māsaṃ adhīte and yojanaṃ kalahaṃ karonto gacchati, which the CST lacks. Malai renders accantasaṃyoge “immediate proximity of time or space”; the Pāḷi says unbroken connection. ↩

  39. One meal does not fill the year, so the connection is not unbroken and the rule does not apply. ↩

  40. Malai (1997) would read gamayati for the CST’s gāmayati; the CST is kept. ↩

  41. Senart’s edition and the Rūpasiddhi read pasūta for the CST’s pasuta, and Malai (1997) prefers it; the CST is kept. ↩

  42. U Nandisena (2005) renders tassa bhavanti vattāro “they are sayers to him”; the vutti’s label evaṃ dutiyatthe makes tassa a sixth in the sense of the second, “there are those who speak of him”. Senart’s edition reads tassa kammassa kattāro for the CST’s sahasā kammassa kattāro. ↩

  43. CST4 prints mahapphala; the Rūpasiddhi and the Saṃyutta read mahapphalaṃ. ↩

  44. CST4 prints gotamī; the Rūpasiddhi and the Majjhima read gotami. Senart’s edition lacks the te before dinne. ↩

  45. CST4 prints gosuduyhamānesu; Senart’s edition and the Rūpasiddhi read gosu duyhamānāsu, which is adopted here. ↩

  46. U Nandisena (2005) renders the vutti “when the agent is used in time and state” and Malai (1997) renders bhāva “the absolute sense”; the Pāḷi says a state, when its agent is expressed. ↩

  47. Senart’s edition, which Malai (1997) prints, reads adhi nacce gotamī for the CST’s naccesu; the CST is kept. ↩

  48. U Nandisena (2005) prints the sutta without ca, Maṇḍit'-ussukkesu tatiyā, as do the manuscripts B1 and T that Malai (1997) reports; Senart’s edition, S1 and S2 carry it. ↩

  49. Malai (1997) renders maṇḍita “adorned”; the vutti’s example pasīdito, “gladdened”, gives the sense taken here. ↩